UPDATE: “Anatomy of an Immigration Debate: Watch Your Mouth, Watch Your Step” Published in HuffPo Latino Voices, Comment Firestorm

The Huffington Post published this blog Op-Ed in HuffPo Latino Voices where for a few minutes, it was the main story, before being bumped by the news that a federal judge is hearing arguments on Alabama’s new immigration law, the toughest in the country.

But I have ample consolation.  The editors also posted it on the front page of the HuffPo!  A tsunami of comments are pouring into “internet newspaper” and this blog, provocative to say the least, in part because readers comment on comments.  Of the many things I deeply appreciate about TWLC community reading is that you leave your name with your comment. This is crucial because we must talk about immigration, no matter how hard, scary, or maddening this issue is to make our country and economy stronger.  By putting your name and face on your thoughts, you encourage us to speak with each other in a civil tone and find resolution.

HuffPost Latino Voices


As it appears in HuffPo Latino Voices:

The White House is scrambling to fix its mensaje and timing problem with Latino voters as demonstrated Thursday by a significant immigration policy change.  Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano announced that approximately 300,000 undocumented immigrants facing deportation will have their cases individually reviewed, and if classified “low priority” can apply for work permits and stay in the U.S. indefinitely.  This includes DREAMers–those who came as young children, graduated from high school, enrolled in college, or served in the armed forces and are seeking citizenship through the stalled DREAM Act.

Why now?  The President, under pressure because of the flatlining economy and the ramp-up to the 2012 election, is facing two emerging verticals in the immigration debate that are compromising the loyalty of Hispanics: breaking his promise to overhaul the immigration system in his first year and accelerated enforcement, specifically bragging about the record deportations–about a million–due in part to of Secure Communities.

President Obama Going to Vacation on Martha's Vineyard

President Obama Courtesy: Mark Wilson/Getty Images

This controversial Department of Homeland Security program requires local law enforcement agents to run FBI fingerprint checks, resulting, according to a White House blog post in:

  • a 70% + increase from 2008 to 2010 in the deportation of those with criminal records and a decrease of those without.
  • More than half of all removals are people with criminal records.
  • Among those deported without criminal records, more than two-thirds were either caught as they crossed the border, had recently arrived, or had been repeatedly removed.

The Administration insists the increased deportations are a result of using existing resources in a more “strategic” way to target and remove illegal immigrants who have committed serious crimes.  Senior White House officials speaking on background on a Thursday conference call acknowledged that as a result of the program’s criticism, improvements are being made, including training local police to not process non-violent immigrants or DREAMers for deportation; exercising more “prosecutorial discretion” to stay removals of those who don’t have criminal records, were nabbed at the border, or are repeat crossers; as well as protecting the witnesses of crime and domestic violence victims.


Fingerprints Courtesy: ICE.gov

This White House message, however, has been falling on deaf ears because the Latino community today is diverse, emboldened by its extraordinary demographic growth, young, and developing a keen, political savvy.  I witnessed this at the National Council of La Raza annual convention when some young advocates in the audience interrupted the President’s speech, demanding he use executive powers to halt the deportations of DREAMers which I blogged about in the post “Anatomy of an Immigration Debate: Presidential Carne Asada at NCLR.”  Protests are erupting across the country and online.  Presente.org (Presente in the context of a roll call means: “Here!”), for example, is circulating a petition to be delivered to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW demanding that President Obama not “force your local police officer to turn people over to immigration,” citing that non-violent immigrants are being rounded up with criminals.

Chicago Secure Communities Protests

Chicago Secure Communities Protests Courtesy: iyjl.org

While it is true that the President does not legislate which is why he needs Congressional support in a Republican-controlled House of Representatives, Latinos believe he is speaking one way to them and in another fashion to the rest of America: breaking his promise of immigration reform, then blaming obstructionist Republicans for refusing to be his “dance partner” versus talking tough, especially to non-Latino audiences, on enforcement.

Any dancer (I’m a big salsera) will confirm that on the dance floor, timing is everything.  On immigration, as well as the economy, the President’s is off.  It is true that the GOP is not forcing its nativist wing to line up behind reform or listening to a sizable part of the business and faith-based community which supports an overhaul.  But if there is one thing worse than having someone refuse your request to dance, it’s being abandoned on the dance floor. Latinos feel the President has done just that.

With the election more than 14 months away, too many factors such as the slow economy and who becomes the GOP nominee are in play to predict the winner of the 2012 presidential contest.

But if a Republican wins because disillusioned and angry Latinos vote GOP, or more likely, sit out the election, President Obama and Democrats have one consolation: the developing political savvy of Hispanics, especially the youth, cuts both ways.  As they increase their participation in the political process, they are learning to channel their inner Independent–the powerful segment of the electorate characterized by flipping parties if the one for which they cast ballots doesn’t deliver.

Some advice for politicians: watch your mouth and your step, or in the next election cycle Latinos will take another Party to the dance floor.

Click to read more of my posts on politics and immigration.


  1. Monica says

    Love it! Such an informative and powerful post. I hate the idea of Latinos sitting out the election. I hope that they continue to give voice to their concerns and demand that politicians and America recognize their value and worth. We have the numbers. We just need to use them.

  2. says

    Great post! And I completely agree with Monica.

    It’s always ironic how people complain about immigration – but for the most part, immigrants come to this country to do the jobs many citizens refuse to do. This country wouldn’t exist and couldn’t survive without the contribution of immigrants. So many forget that.

    And in the debate of immigration – Mexico and Spanish speaking countries are always the target. However their are Albanians, Russians, Irish and many other illegal immigrants here also but I guess they are easier to blend in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>