Senator McCain’s Definition of Illegal Could Mean You

Senior Arizona Senator and former Republican presidential candidate John McCain ignited a firestorm of criticism over his comments last weekend that the tragic wildfires raging in his state were set by “people who have crossed our border illegally.” He immediately called for tighter border security.

Watch the video courtesy of TheZenoEffect/CNN/KTVK:

Although a U.S. Forest Service spokesperson rejected that the cause of the Monument Fire at the Coronado National Memorial was sparked by undocumented immigrants, the Senator didn’t back down when Good Morning America‘s George Stephanopoulos asked him Tuesday one question about the combustible comment.

Watch the interview courtesy of ABC News which ends at 1:54:

Here is where McCain’s facts get mixed up, “The Monument fire was started when the park, when the forest was closed. So anyone in there is illegal.”

Indeed, the Senator is correct.  Anyone in the park after hours is there illegally, an affirmation that the National Park Service website confirms: “The Memorial is open year round from dawn to dusk.”

However, park rules clearly state that ANYONE in the forest after the sun sets is violating the policy, regardless of immigration status.

Although it is likely that at least one wildfire in history has been sparked by illegal immigrants who are trying to, in the words of the Senator, “signal others,” “keep warm”, or “divert law enforcement agents, agencies”, McCain omitted other common culprits such as arsonists or campers who fail to fully snuff out a camp fire.

Unfortunately, George did not press McCain on his answer because the GMA anchor moved to news of the day–troop withdrawals from Afghanistan.

The blogosphere and social media, though, are inflamed and accusing the Senator of dragging immigration reform into the devastating Monument Fire, dousing this debate with gasoline, then throwing in a lit match.

McCain is a war hero who has a track record of honorable service that spans decades in the Navy and in the U.S. Senate.  This includes co-sponsoring with the late Senator Ted Kennedy the imperfect Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2005 which failed, in part because critics argued it granted illegal immigrants amnesty.

Without conclusive evidence that undocumented workers sparked the Monument Fire, the Senator needs to immediately apologize for diverting attention from this devastating event.  As important, he should return to his independent streak and earlier tendency to reach across the political aisle to fix our broken immigration system with sensible reform which ultimately will dampen the fiery tenor of anti-immigrants, strengthen the U.S. economy in part by forcing companies to pay payroll taxes, and unify divided families.


  1. Tom Bessette says

    After decades of exceptionally honorable and valuable service, McCain sold out to the right wing in his presidential bid. He suddenly lost his independence and started pandering to the ‘base’. He partnered with a right wing flake, thus jumpstarting her national prominence to the point where it is frighteningly possible that someone like her could actually be elected to our highest office. McCain continues to cravenly suck up to the modern know nothings, long after losing his highest office bid. Too bad, too, too bad. There was a time I very much respected him, though I often disagreed, because I believed he was honest and interested in what was best for the country. No more. The damage he has done and continues to do to the national dialog has more than canceled out his past honor. Shame on you, Senator; time to fade away with your tarnished legacy.

    • Patrick says

      I always wonder why McCain is called a war hero. He went to war when he was told to, he dropped bombs where he was told to, he got shot down, he was a POW. I have heard that he could have been released back early in a prisoner swap, but that he refused to because then his career in he Navy would be over.
      If he is a hero than everyone who served is a hero. He is simply a veteran.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>